Monday, November 27, 2023

The Mystical Teaching of St. John of the Cross

                   The Mystical Teaching of St. John of the Cross

Do use the toggle below : example at the 13th minute : What is contemplation:

and there's a lot of call it bad information floating around out there in the Catholic World about
what contemplation is and and we have vocal meditative and contemplative prayer and John is obviously a master of
this is there a way to describe contemplative prayer for people in a way
that they can kind of sink their teeth into it's actually Matthew a that's a more
difficult question than uh it was a trick question I knew I kind of
set you up there but I was looking for some help from you because you're the expert on John Lacross and so I always
have difficulty in kind of describing this because you see John calls it the fragrance of God and and there's all
these kinds of kind of um vague descriptions of the Saints why is that
yeah I think because uh you know the strict meaning of contemplation will be
a Grace that's given to the soul you know with a
certain advancement in spiritual life and then that affects the interior life of Prayer
and John lacrosse will have a lot of pages you know speaking of the
transitional time when you are praying in a more ordinary fashion you might be
praying for years in a dedicated manner but it's still a more ordinary approach


    
rare people that the more you read him the more you realize you have a lot more to understand so we're going to peel
back the onion a bit more on the teaching of this mystical doctor in the art of Catholic today because he reached
the heights of Union with God and he has an immense amount to teach us welcome to
the program I'm Matthew Leonard my guest today is someone I believe to be one of the Premier modern voices in authentic
Catholic spirituality father Donald Haggerty he's an expert on prayer and has a deep love of the mystical Theology
and teaching of Saint John of the Cross father Hagerty is a priest of the Archdiocese of New York he serves at St
Patrick's Cathedral he taught moral Theology and worked as a spiritual director in seminaries for 20 years he's
the author of a number of books such as contemplative hunger and contemplative enigmas and his latest Title St John of
the Cross master of contemplation is absolutely phenomenal I love this book
it is deep in my own in love of John of the Cross and has helped me fall even more in love with Jesus Christ and his
church which after all is the goal so it is my privilege to have this discussion with him father Hagerty welcome to the
art of Catholic thank you so much Matthews that was very nice your introduction thank you but you and I
have never met in person but I want you to know you've had a profound effect on me and my understanding of Saint John of
the Cross he's been near and dear to my heart for a long time and he's very much at the heart of the talks that I give
around the country and things that I teach in the science of sainthood and I have to say that your latest book is the
best that I've ever read on him in fact I haven't even I haven't even finished it yet because I have so many notes
inside of this thing I can't get through it so you've done an incredible uh service to the church I think in taking
what's oftentimes complicated and deep teaching and you've made it very accessible and I'm curious
um how it is that you kind of got into this I mean not not everyone falls in love
with the spiritual life in the same way that you have but how did you discover John of the Cross and fall in love with his teachings
well that goes back to my time um actually before the Seminary and then
I I entered uh the missionary charity fathers Mother Teresa's order uh when it
was just beginning in 1984 and one of the priests who joined at that time and
he was my initial uh Superior was a priest from Spain who had studied
in Toledo and loved Saint John of the cross in fact he said his spiritual director of the Seminary did not allow
his men to read further in John of the Cross until he they had permission from one section to
another so of course I was curious fascinated and then uh a great uh providential
thing was in my first year in the Seminary at that time I asked one of the
professors who had been the Rector of the Seminary back in the 1960s into the
70s I asked him if he would do a private study with me for credit
on Pope John Paul II's dissertation Faith according to Saint John of the
Cross which had been published by Ignatius press and there it is there is
some reason too and I uh read through that work with this very great Monsignor
Montano and most of that work uh three quarters of that is on a small section
of Saint John of the cross is the beginning of his the second book of uh the ascent of Mount Carmel nine
chapters or so it's not too long but it's a very concentrated treatment on the importance of the theological virtue
of faith on the intellect and how it affects contemplation so that got me hooked and at that point then I had my
copy of Saint John of the Cross and began the underlining that even to this day continues in my genre of the Cross
collected works yeah that's beautiful in fact why don't we do this when we said a
little bit of context as we move into move into this discussion of him give us a little bit of a biographical sketch of
the mystical doctor because a lot of people have heard bits and pieces maybe they've heard of The Dark Knight of the Soul or whatever but they don't really
know who he is so give us a little bit of background if you would okay his dates are 1542 to 1591 and as your
listeners viewers know that that was right in the middle of of the Protestant
Reformation in fact his he was born just before the beginning of the Council of
Trent and he grew up uh poor his father
died when he was young uh and apparently you know a beautiful uh Beginnings uh
and he joined the Carmelite Order after working with Jesuits in a hospital and
then at the time of his ordination in 1567 at 25 years old Teresa of Avila
centuries of Avila had already started the con the Carmelite reform five years
earlier and he went to see her weeks after his ordination and then she he was about to
become a carthusian at that point so clearly he already had you know serious
depth in his interior life and spirituality's prayer he was going to shift over to the carthusians you know
the Great contemplative order of man monastic order and Teresa valvela convinced him
no try to or I want to do a reform also of the men's branch of the carmelites so
he took up her offer and with another priest very shortly after they began the
men's uh reform of their Carmelite Order and what's interesting he had 10 more or
less quiet years he was five years a Confessor in the famous Convent of incarnation in Avila
and then at that point 10 years into his priesthood he was kidnapped by his own calcid order
because of you could think resentment toward the reform at that point and he spent nine months very
significant in his life nine months imprisoned in what was a converted
closet in the monastery of the of the carmelites
and in Toledo and then he escaped after those nine months the understanding is
that he composed his famous poem the spiritual Canticle during those
nine months he was in a closet there which had only a slit of light up on the top of the wall so he was mostly in in
darkness literal Darkness for that time and he had no pen or paper he had these
verses memorized and he lived what we would say his own Dark Night of the soul in that time
he came out escaped and then he became the great Saint John of the Cross he actually only wrote his commentary on
that some years later it's significant that he wrote the great for treatises only in the last
seven years of his life which to me is very striking the you know it's it's a fairly thick book you know the four
treatises is collected works and you know without computers without being able to probably rewrite things it's an
amazing uh uh body of work that he put together then at the request then of his
Carmelite Sisters for more teaching on contemplation
speaking of contemplation let's kind of get into why John is so important because when
we're talking about John lacrosse we're talking about the movement of our soul toward God and and prayer is obviously
at the heart of that movement and as Catholics you know we know a lot of prayers but maybe we haven't ever moved
deeply into conversation with god can you elaborate just for a second as a
pastor as a former spiritual as a spiritual director I mean why is deeper prayer so vitally important for Catholics
well I think it's a it's just a Law of Spiritual life that the depth of our
prayer life you know the purity of our desire for God if it carves greater
depth into our inner Spirit that's always going to overflow and radiate
into our activity and even in kind of quiet influence that we may have on
others you know we hear Jesus saying a number of times in in John's gospel asking us to bear fruit if you abide in
me and I abide in you you will bear much fruit and really the life of prayer is
the key to that and I mean it's been often a criticism in our own time that
the activist you know Spirit of you know being very active maybe working
24 hours a day even as a religious or a priest not that anybody does that but
that that's going to be you know then the external fruits of our life but John
of the Cross is very insistent I think all the saints would say and agree you have to have a serious life of Prayer
you know seeking striving for Union with God and then he uses you know the person
much more uh effectively in the world no I said Luke 10 you know Mary and
Martha's story and Martha being anxious and Mary has chosen the one thing necessary that interior relationship
with our Lord it has to be active contemplation is it should be called contemplative action I think we should
move into prayer first and then everything flows out of that but what are some of the obstacles that you have found in your role as a priest and
spiritual director common obstacles that would prevent people from moving into deeper prayer and I know John talks
about this and you mention this in your book as well well I think it's sometimes it's a a
need for everyone to uh to choose and to choose quiet time that we have to and
many people will say I'm too busy too busy for life is uh hectic and
overwhelming um but I think we have to choose and depends on one's uh state of life if you
have young children at home well children take a nap also sometimes or
you know sometimes you get up earlier and sometimes I tell this story that when I was a priest I was close then to
Mother Teresa's sisters and new Mother Teresa and in the years when she was
alive and one time when I was studying in Rome moral Theology and my you know preparing
to be a seminary professor some of us who knew Mother Teresa asked
her some priests we asked her if she would give a little talk for us so she was gracious enough to give this
talk to about eight of us I believe maybe ten and during that talk she had a sense of humor but she said in a kind of
serious way she said I think the biggest problem in the priesthood
is that the priests stay up too late watching TV and they don't get up in the morning to
pray and if someone's essential to get up early in the morning to pray
so you know some of these things are choices and then you know there are
other obstacles you know I think there's a serious obstacle which I've written in other books you know the technological
distractions that now um you know are of our time that kind of
obsessive turning to the cell phone and information and you know feeding off
these things that does have a deleterious effect perhaps on a more
recollected quiet in our lives well I think that's the key isn't it how in the world can you possibly recollect
yourself when you've got all this garbage you know it's bouncing around inside of your head and Teresa of Avila
talks about this to the point where she says it becomes a venial sin if you continue to do these things knowing that
you're interrupting your time of prayer because you're making an act of the will to choose something other than God even
though you know it's has a deleterious effect on your on your time in prayer so right it's an act of the will we have to
make a decision that we're going to do this and I think that one of the things that we don't realize as Catholics that
we're literally made to pray like this is we're created to be in this Union with God and prayer is the way that we
achieve this Union obviously based on the sacraments as well but you can't say you have a relationship with the Lord if
you don't set this time aside to pray because you know if I if I show if I
treated my wife the way that I used to treat my relationship with the Lord we wouldn't have a very good marriage you
know because there would be no communication so we have to make an act of the will
um you know you the subtitle of your book um is master of contemplation
and there's a lot of call it bad information floating around out there in the Catholic World about
what contemplation is and and we have vocal meditative and contemplative prayer and John is obviously a master of
this is there a way to describe contemplative prayer for people in a way
that they can kind of sink their teeth into it's actually Matthew a that's a more
difficult question than uh it was a trick question I knew I kind of
set you up there but I was looking for some help from you because you're the expert on John Lacross and so I always
have difficulty in kind of describing this because you see John calls it the fragrance of God and and there's all
these kinds of kind of um vague descriptions of the Saints why is that
yeah I think because uh you know the strict meaning of contemplation will be
a Grace that's given to the soul you know with a
certain advancement in spiritual life and then that affects the interior life of Prayer
and John lacrosse will have a lot of pages you know speaking of the
transitional time when you are praying in a more ordinary fashion you might be
praying for years in a dedicated manner but it's still a more ordinary approach
to prayer with meditation with some reflection you know perhaps seeking
emotional satisfactions in prayer wanting to feel close to God you know
many things that are of the natural level you know Grace but
the movement into a an advancement in grace to contemplation is a opening of
God to communicate himself more to the Soul at a certain point and and I think
the um the reality of this is you know we should all be conscious we
want more of God and if we realize that God is very personal
he's very personal so if we pray before a tabernacle we're not praying before just a sacred place there or you know
where he is you know concealed behind the doors of that Tabernacle or there
you know under the appearance of a host and a monstrance but the real person is
there so the desire of all of us is really to come to have a more unique you know real
contact and encounter communication with this reality of Our Lord the Paradox of
this is that it may we may enter into a greater sense of Mystery the more that we enter or get you know
draw closer respond receptively to our Lord the greater mystery takes over
prayer so you know just as an introductory you know statement there
that's it's not a question so much of vagueness that you know that we say well you're not really answering the quote
what is contemplation let's have a definition but you know John of the Cross will say this is an interior
experience in prayer that because God is Ultimate mystery even in love and desire
for us that some of that experience will not be able to have um be nailed down in
very you know clear language on the other hand a person will say yes
I have there's something more of God in my life now more than ever
yeah and it's not uh when we talk about an experience it doesn't necessarily mean it's going to overflow into some
kind of sensory experience and I think this is where a lot of people get lost when trying to figure out what contemplation is because the reason why
the Saints have such a difficulty at times to express this mystery that's taking place is because what's happening
is our own deification and divinization which is something that frankly goes beyond the boundaries of human language
you can't really describe what's happening when God is infusing himself into you in this infused contemplation
it's nothing we can make happen which I think is one of the big confusions that's out there today there are a lot
of different modern people teaching you know that you can
kind of Center down or say some mantras or whatever and all of a sudden you've entered into contemplation contemplation
is all God I mean we have a job to get ready for it through vocal and meditative prayer and living the life of
virtue uh but only he can do it to us and that's that mysterious experience of
him and as you kind of alluded to uh implicitly this mystery moves us into
not uh a deeper necessarily sensory experience of him but more kind of into
darkness and this is a theme that you see play out and you mentioned uh John
Paul II's dissertation on faith and he deals a great deal with this as moving
into darkness even as the virtue of faith is growing we sometimes feel this as a Darkness why is Darkness such a
powerful uh symbol for John lacrosse will the darkness saw especially in the
in the intellects ex experience of prayer may uh intensify in a certain
manner you know as our as our prayer advances you know all the time if we give ourselves more fully to God and you
know it's one thing I think we all are satisfied when you know if we have a new a new
insight or some reflection you know it makes some connection between things or
we see something new in the gospel we haven't seen before but John lacrosse is going to teach that
and he's rooting his teaching in Saint Thomas Aquinas that the theological
virtue of faith actually unites the intellect to God himself
and so that's a profound thing that the the intellect which you know only has limited capacity in its natural uh
you know reality as a faculty is going to be overcome with certain obscurity as
we go forward uh in our self-giving to God and you know the result is I mean there's a
great statement of John of the Cross is that as Faith increases certitude increases
for the certitude of being in the presence of Our Lord the presence of all Lord in a chapel in
front of a tabernacle certitude increases but Clarity does not increase

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  1:57 How Fr. Haggerty Discovered St. John of the Cross 4:13 Biographical Sketch of St. John of the Cross 7:56 Why Deeper Prayer is Vitally Important for Catholics 9:54 Common Obstacles to Deeper Prayer 12:40 We Were Made to Pray 13:11 What is Contemplation? 17:54 Why Darkness is a Powerful Symbol for St. John of the Cross 23:03 Definition and Purpose of Asceticism 27:12 How to Practice Asceticism in Daily Life 32:20 What is Mental Austerity? 38:48 St. John of the Cross on Detachment from the World and Self-Abandonment to God 44:00 Understanding Dryness in Prayer 45:16 If Fr. Haggerty Had One Last Homily 46:15 Meditating on the Gospels 48:10 Spiritual Reading as a Bridge to Contemplation 52:01 Blessing St. John of the Cross is one of the most celebrated, yet misunderstood spiritual teachers in the Catholic faith. But the more we understand the mystical and powerful teaching of this spiritual giant, the more deeply we'll move into relationship with Christ. Join Matthew Leonard and Fr. Donald Haggerty as they unveil the beautiful teaching of the Mystical Doctor. Topics covered include: • What are some common obstacles to deeper prayer? • What is the real role of asceticism? • The importance of "mental austerity" • The theme of darkness in John of the Cross • St. John Paul II's love of St. John of the Cross and his fascinating view of the virtue of faith • and more!

Reflections: St John of the Cross-Carmelite Mystics

The Carmelite Mystics is a series of reflections presented by Fr Steven Payne, OCD during Lent 2022 for the Cathedral of St Matthew in Washi...